Claimed AI-assisted

Cable knot counterexamples to the full-sequence volume conjecture for all knots

Haibin Hang, with OpenAI Codex assisting, shows that for the (1,2)-cable of the connected sum of two figure-eight knots the growth rate of the colored Jones polynomial does not converge along all colors, so the volume conjecture's full-sequence limit fails for knots in general, extending parity effects Lê and Tran found for cables in 2009.

Model
OpenAI Codex; version not stated
Field
Mathematics
Date
2026-11-06
Human collaborators
Haibin Hang

What was found

The volume conjecture says the normalized logarithmic growth of a knot's colored Jones polynomial at q=e2πi/Nq = e^{2\pi i/N} tends to its simplicial volume times the volume of the regular ideal tetrahedron. For the (p,w)(p, w)-cable of the connected sum of d≥2d \ge 2 copies of the figure-eight knot EE, with w≥2w \ge 2 and p,wp, w coprime, the paper shows the growth rate converges to the JSJ volume dVdV along colors coprime to 2w2w, while its upper limit along colors sharing a divisor with ww is at most VV. So the (1,2)-cable of E#EE \# E violates the full-sequence limit, and the (1,3)-cable shows convergence can fail even along all odd colors. The all-color upper limit still agrees with the JSJ volume. The separation comes from the multiples of NN in the exact cabling sum and a uniform first-derivative estimate for the other companion colors.

Novelty check

arXiv, 2026-11-19, abs:"volume conjecture" AND abs:cable returned 5 records. The closest is Lê and Tran, On the volume conjecture for cables of knots (arXiv:0907.0172, J. Knot Theory Ramifications 2010), whose abstract already states that for many cables of the figure-eight knot the volume conjecture is false over all colors but holds on a subset of colors. The paper cites Lê and Tran for parity effects in cable links and for the odd-cable case; its family, cables of connected sums of figure-eight knots, is different. Nothing in this registry covers the volume conjecture beyond a mention inside 2026-08-01-astra-ten-advances, which concerns Ehrhart's volume conjecture, an unrelated problem.

Caveats and known objections

Held at claimed, with a novelty caveat that matters: that the full-sequence limit can fail for cable knots was already shown by Lê and Tran in 2009, so what is new is the specific composite-companion family and its clean separation of color classes, not the existence of counterexamples. A five-page single-author preprint, unrefereed, with no outside reader on record. vibemathed's listing title reads as if the conjecture were resolved for all knots, which inverts the paper. The acknowledgement says only that Codex 'assisted with developing and checking the argument and preparing the manuscript', which does not say which steps it produced. Autonomy is ai-assisted on the strictest reading of that wording.

Also recorded at

vibemathedthe-all-knot-volume-conjecture

Nothing mechanically. It is a parallel listing of the same result, carrying its own verification label rather than an independent check.

The listing's title frames the result as the volume conjecture for all knots; the paper is a disproof of its full-sequence form for one family.

No independent check is recorded on this entry yet.

Reading the primary source closely enough to say whether it supports the claim counts as a check, and you are credited on the entry.

Or on GitHub: submit a check challenge the grade send a correction or send a pull request

Entry history (1 event)
  1. AddedEntered the registry graded Claimed and AI-assisted.

Entries are never deleted. A grade that does not hold up is downgraded on the record, with the reason beside it.

Graded claimed for verification and ai-assisted for autonomy. What these mean.

Cite this entry

Plain text
whataifound.org. (2026). Cable knot counterexamples to the full-sequence volume conjecture for all knots. whataifound.org: A Registry of AI Scientific and Mathematical Discoveries. https://whataifound.org/finding/2026-11-06-cable-knot-volume-conjecture
BibTeX
@misc{whataifound-independent-2026-conjecture,
  title        = {Cable knot counterexamples to the full-sequence volume conjecture for all knots},
  author       = {{whataifound.org}},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {whataifound.org: A Registry of AI Scientific and Mathematical Discoveries},
  note         = {Result by Independent. Verification: Claimed. Autonomy: AI-assisted.},
  url          = {https://whataifound.org/finding/2026-11-06-cable-knot-volume-conjecture}
}

Related findings

← All mathematics findings in the registry